Choosing a security seal starts with understanding what your application requires. For procurement, logistics and supply chain security teams, the letters I, S and H provide an important distinction. Under the ISO 17712, these classifications mean:
- I – Indicative
- S – Security
- H – High Security
Each describes a different level of physical resistance. Understanding the difference helps you write clearer specifications, compare products and ask suppliers for the right supporting documentation.
This guide explains the three classifications and what to check before placing an order.
What is ISO 17712?
ISO 17712 is the international standard for mechanical freight container seals. It establishes procedures for their classification, acceptance and withdrawal, providing a common reference for seals used to secure freight containers in international commerce. The current published edition is ISO 17712:2013, which was reviewed and confirmed in 2023.
A mechanical seal forms part of a wider security process. It helps reveal evidence of tampering, and depending on its construction and classification, provides resistance to attempts to open it. Executive use also depends on how seals are selected, store, issued, applied, recorded and inspected.
ISO 17712 classifications at a glance
Full name: Indicative Seal
Physical resistance and removal: Relatively easy to remove by hand or with a simple cutting tool.
Full name: Security Seal
Physical resistance and removal: Provides limited resistance to intrusion and requires lightweight tools for removal.
Full name: High Security Seal
Physical resistance and removal: Designed to delay intrusion; substantial bolt cutters or cable cutters are generally needed for removal.
What is an Indicative (I) Seal?
An indicative seal is constructed from material that can be broken by hand or removed using a simple snipping tool or shear. The key consideration is its relatively low physical resistance. Buyers should establish whether that level of resistance is appropriate for the application before specifying the product.
As with other seal classes, users must inspect the seal to identify evidence of tampering. A seal’s presence alone does not establish that it has remained intact throughout its use.
What should buyers check?
Confirm that the proposed product’s documented classification matches the requirement. Avoid assuming that a seal meets an application’s needs simply because it is described as ‘tamper evident’.
What is a security (S) seal?
A security seal provides limited resistance to intrusion and requires lightweight tools for removal. The distinction matters because ‘security seal’ is also used as a broad commercial description. A product listing that uses those words may leave its ISO 17712 classification unclear.
When class S is required, the specification should state that requirement explicitly and identify the evidence the supplier must provide.
What should buyers check?
Ask the supplier to confirm the classification for the exact product model being offered. Match the supporting documentation to that model rather than relying on a general statement about the supplier’s range.
What is a high security (H) seal?
A high security seal is designed and constructed to delay intrusion. Such seals generally require substantial bolt cutters or cable cutters for removal.
Where your shipment, customer or security programme requires class H, verify that the proposed product has the relevant supporting evidence. Appearance alone is insufficient. A robust locking bolt or cable seal should not be treated as proof of a high security classification.
What should buyers check?
Confirm the exact model, its documented classification and whether it meets the requirements applicable to your shipment. A classification does not establish universal acceptance for every route, customer or security programme.
What is the difference between I, S and H seals?
The main difference is the level of physical resistance described by each classification.
Indicative seals are relatively easy to remove. Security seals provide limited resistance and need lightweight tools for removal. High security seals are designed to delay intrusion and generally require more substantial cutting tools.
Howver, selecting a seal involves more than comparing resistance. The required classification must also fit the application, and the selected product must work with your equipment and operating procedures.
Common mistakes when specifying security seals
Using security seal as the complete specification
The phrase may leave the required classification, product identity and supporting evidence undefined. State those requirements clearly so purchasing, suppliers and operations work from the same information.
Choosing by appearance alone
Material, size and product photographs do not establish an ISO 17712 classification. Verify the specific model’s documentation.
Treating a classification as a complete security process
A suitable seal still needs correct application, recording and inspection. Build those steps into your operating procedures.
Assuming high security means tamper proof
High security seals are designed to delay intrusion. They do not provide a guarantee against theft or tampering.
Comparing price before confirming suitability
Check that each proposed product meets the same requirement before comparing costs. Otherwise, quotations may cover products with different classifications or capabilities.
Need help choosing a security seal?
Start with your application and required classification. Then compare specific products and their supporting documentation.
When requesting a recommendation, provide details of the closure, intended use and any customer or shipment requirements. This helps us recommend a suitable seal and explain the evidence behind it.